There are three possible explanations for his actions. So with Odysseus actually still alive, the suitors could be gotten rid of only if Odysseus himself did it. Then when she left she turned into a bird. There, he finds many suitors desiring to occupy his position and marry his wife. Nora has no second thoughts of borrowing money to save her husband. Like a tree, solid and long-lasting, Odysseus and Penelope refuse to uproot themselves and join with another partner to create a new family. Polybus. Why did Amphinomus suddenly change his mind about plotting to kill Telemachus? The suitors were trying to marry his wife and it's always ok to kill anyone who is trying to marry your wife. We can say that Hamlet murders Polonius because he is simply deranged, because he tries to feign his madness, or maybe he is just so self absorbed that he does not know himself anymore. The doctor informs her, it [is] necessary he should have no idea what a dangerous condition he [is] in (p. 1357) and that a warmer climate is what he needs to get better. After this, Odysseus took his place as the rightful king of Ithaca. LitCharts Teacher Editions. What is Odysseus worried about if he does kill all of the suitors? Thankfully, the goddess Athena helps Odysseus reclaim his home by coming up with a plan to kill the suitors, which mostly involves Odysseus becoming enraged enough to defeat the foul suitors. To start off, the suitors help themselves to possessions from Odysseus's home whenever the need seemed to arise. They fed them to no end and this is not what their master would want them do to. 5. They fed them to no end and this is not what their master would want them do to. The only person who doesn 't run away from Odysseus is Nausicaa because Athena gave her the courage to stand up to him. Also, he truly loves Jane, and she loves him too, so hes not manipulating her into marrying him. Copyright 2020 IPL.org All rights reserved. 1. The servant who proves to be a kind and faithful servant is Philioitios. Would not have made it through AP Literature without the printable PDFs. Instead of slandering the Maids for their sexual promiscuity, Penelope emphasizes their youth, beauty, and their experience of sexual violence, giving a more sympathetic account of their characters. And for this, she was held up as an example of constancy and virtue. Among them are: 2. Sjjsjenzns Sjjsjenzns 01/31/2021 English College answered What is Odysseus worried about if he does kill all of the suitors? Odysseus, with the help of Telemachus, slays the suitors for two main reasons. What or whom is Athena disguised as? At a signal, the prince is to gather all the weapons and place them in the storeroom. After the Trojan war and ten years of wandering, he returns home. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. Nanny merely wanted Janie to be in a safe relationship, and therefore, she arranged the marriage with him. It is not pure luck that Nausicaa helps Odysseus because Athena mostly planned all of it and she just left it up Nausicca good conscience and Odysseus ' good wisdom. Teachers and parents! Its worse than the first lie as this is committing bigamy, which is a crime. 2. Who proves himself to be kind and faithful servant? He is killed 2nd. Athena helps Odysseus by motivating him. It also displays that Hilly deeply treasures her reputation because of her reaction towards the situation. firm of purpose! Odysseus, with the help of Telemachus, slays the suitors for two main reasons. Aided by his son Telemachus and a few trusty servants, Odysseus slaughters the suitors. I think Odysseus will kill all of the bad suitors and servants and let the good servants and maids live. Why do Telemachos and his mother need Odysseus? More importantly, by taking advantage of his absence, the suitors have insulted Odysseus and damaged his reputation. Through deception and desperation, Macbeth convinces men to murder Banquo so he could remain. Struggling with distance learning? Subsequently, question is, how does Athena help Odysseus in Book 22? 3. Odysseus kill all of the Suitors with the help of his son Telemachus. The way the content is organized, LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in, Storytelling, Textual Authority, and Falsehoods, Antiquity, Modernity, and Progress for Women. Odysseus proves his true identity by being the only one who can use the bow and arrow and shoot the arrow through the. But Torvald refuses to get a loan even when Noras request she would like to travel abroad like other young wives (p. 1357), Nora has no choice but to lie to get the money herself. 4. They have wasted a lot of his wealth, by living at his expense during his absence. Odysseus then revealed his identity to Eumaeus and Philoetius and recruited them Also, when the suitors are throwing their spears and shooting, she made it so that Odysseus and his men could not be hit by the suitors, but when they aim at the suitors, Athena made it so that they 2. Who is the only person who doesnt run away from the terrifying Odysseus? Unfortunately, their marriage is absent of true feelings as Janie does not genuinely love Logan. Why does Odysseuss wife have suitors? Yes it was harsh for Odysseus to brutally kill all of the maids and suitors but they deserved it. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. Does Nausicaa believe her parents will help Odysseus? The men don 't want Odysseus to try to string the bow because they don 't want a beggar to marry Penelopeia. Odysseus to be her husband. Description: He is the swineherd who helps Odysseus kill all of the suitors. With the help of Telemachus, he manages to trick all the suitors and then kill them. Penelope does not want the Gods to save Telemachus so that he may live on, but so that he can return to her and keep her from being alone for the rest of her life, as well as. 3. The Suitors were trying to marry Penelope and kill their son Telemachus. What do you think Odysseus is going to do to the suitors? While Eurycleia thinks he did not do so because he respected her, it was actually because of Laertes fear of Anticleia. Penelopeia 's challenge for the suitors was to shoot an arrow through the twelve axes that hung from the ceiling. Lady Macbeth has an undeviating desire in having more power and making her husband the king. The motives behind Odysseus's will to kill the suitors is understandable. By successfully persuading Macbeth into murdering the king this shows that Lady Macbeth is controlling towards people and she can be a very manipulative person. Athena helps Odysseus and Telemachus kill all the wicked men, both striking at foes herself and protecting them from harm. Amphinomus saw an omen of a high flying eagle with a dove in its talons. Telemachus is to return to town and mix with the suitors. If Odysseus said he would kill all the 108 suitors himself then why did he bring Athena and Telemachus into the mini-war. Why don 't the men want Odysseus to try to string the bow? Though Eurycleia judges the Maids for being rape victims, she could easily be in their place. father of Eurymachus killed by Eumaeus with a spear. Odysseus (/ o d s i s, o d s ju s /; Greek: , , translit. Philoetius is Odysseus's master After all of them failed to do it, Odysseus shot the arrow and won the contest. When the time comes to kill the suitors Odysseus only trusts Telemachos, Philioitios, and Eumaios. This is why Odysseus was justified to kill them. In chapter 23 of To Kill a Mockingbird, Aunt Alexandra did not allow Scout to play with Walter Cunningham because of his poor background. sender: johntesting. They made no effort to get the suitors out of the house. Nausicaa believes that her parents will help Odysseus because they have an obligation in which all Greeks have to help strangers and feed them like they are family, also Odysseus is a good person, and Athena makes it seem like Odysseus is a God to them. They made no effort to get the suitors out of the house. Philoetius, Eumaeus, and Telemachus help Odysseus kill the suitors. A great deal of independence is portrayed by Janie when she decides to leave her marriage with Logan in favor of Joe Starks. Odysseus swears her to secrecy, threatening to kill her if she tells anyone. Odysseus then summoned Eurycleia and told her to indicate which Maids had been disloyal. At The goddess Athena helps Odysseus throughout these books. He tries to blame Antiniousfor all of the suitors actions. Antinous . When you durst do it, then you were a man; And to be more than what you were, you would be so much more the man. (1.7.47-51). Macbeth would have never went through with killing King Duncan if Lady Macbeth had never persuaded him because he really does have a soft heart and is good and honorable. Philoetius is Odysseus's master cowherd in the Odyssey. Book XXI. 1 See answer Sjjsjenzns is waiting for your help. The fact that Odysseus won 't bathe in front of the girls tells us that he is very modest. 2)The suitors dont want the beggar Odysseus to try to string the bow because theyre afraid that he might be able to actually do it. Next, Odysseus, with the aid of his son Telemachus and a few loyal followers, kills all the suitors. Indeed Melanthius seems fit for the death penalty as he has been disloyal to Odysseus the most. Character: Eurynomos, Amphimedon, Demoptolemos, Peisandros, and Polybos Once Athena enters the battle, armed with her man-destroying shield of thunder, the terrified suitors stop fighting and scatter, allowing Odysseus and his men to ruthlessly slaughter them. It shows that she is the type of person that gets things done by manipulating other people to do her dirty work for her. 3 years, 5 months ago permalink. How does Odysseus prove his true identity? They recklessly disregard the property and they rape and seduce Penelopes Maids. The suitors had to use Odysseus bow and arrow to shoot through the holes of twelve ax-heads. While most of the suitors are not dealt with individually by Homer, some are mentioned by name and play more or less significant roles in the poem. In the Greek tragedy Antigone, Antigone learns that King Creon refuses to give a proper burial for Polynecies, brother of Ismene and Antigone. sender: johntesting. Who attempts to rally the suitors and get them to attack Odysseus? When the contest of the bow begins, none of the suitors is able to string the bow. Give me the daggers. When Odysseus returns to Ithaca, he and Telemachus kill all of the Suitors. Theoclymenus. Add your answer and earn points. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!, This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. When Eurycleia points out which of the Maids said negative things about Odysseus, she not only betrays members of her gender, but also members of her class. Antigone shares this with Ismene, she refuses to help Antigone bury her brother and thinks the decree that Creon has implemented are for everyones safety and well-being. Yes it was harsh for Odysseus to brutally kill all of the maids and suitors but they deserved it. Penelope pushes back against Eurycleias classification of the Maids as notorious whores, showing that the way that violence against women gets recounted matters. Though the suitors refuse at first, Penelope intervenes and allows the "stranger" to participate. This incident shows the reader that she wants to be taken seriously by her colleagues. Protective love is exhibited by Nanny as she is a caring grandmother and wants Janie to be financially stable and safe. IV.862). Subsequently, a nurse, Eurycleia, comes to Penelopes aid and advises her to pray to the Gods to help Telemachus. Get the answers you need, now! In the twenty-second book of Homer 's Odyssey, Odysseus begins his battle with the suitors. Odysseus, in disguise, will follow. As well as. Notably, and ironically, Eurycleia could have been a notorious whore herself had Laertes raped her in her youth, as she discusses earlier. In the fight between Odysseus and the suitors he sides with the suitors, supplying them with equipment for battle. Meanwhile, Eurycleia and the other women listened at the door of the womens quarters. First, they were disrespectful to him and his household, especially the first ones he and his son target with Telemachos and his mother, Penelopeia, need Odysseus because there are suitors in his house trying to take Penelopeia 's hand in marriage and the suitors are always eating at This is why Odysseus was justified to kill them. He disregards the suitors' attempt for an apology and kills them all with the help of his servants and Telemachus. The Suitors feast every day at Ithaca, eating away at Odysseuss fortune and Telemachus s inheritance. All of Noras deception begins as an act of love for her husband, Torvald. Assignment On Odysseus In Book One Of The Book 'The Odyssey'. Book I. His motives are purely to trick Jane into marrying him even though he is already married. In this manner, why did Odysseus kill the suitors? Character: Athena (disguised as Mentor) Description:Athena disguises herself as Mentor and sits on the rafters during the fighting. After all the suitors have given up, the disguised Odysseus asks to participate. Now its not all terrible. If he does, then it would be absolutely embarrassing for the suitors. Christian Gonzalez Gonzalez 1 Lady Macbeth can simply achieve her own goals by getting into anyones head and turning their own conscience against them in, which is essentially what she did to her husband. In book one Athena is disguised as Ments, the son of Anchialos. All they did was aide the suitors. 3 years, 5 months ago permalink. loyal cowherd of Odysseus, helps Odysseus kill the suitors by locking up the gates. Odysseus knows he will have to call on Apollo and ask for his help to assure his success. -Graham S. Penelopes conspiracy theory about Eurycleias knowledge of Penelopes secret espionage with the Maids adds to the sense of the text being comprised of numerous, conflicting narratives without objective truth. 4. Mentor. What does the fact that Odysseus wont bathe in front of the girls tell us about the kind of person he is? Athena only physically engages in the battle once Odysseus and Telemachus have proven their worthiness by fighting with determination. A loyal servant of Odysseus, who helps him fight the suitors with Philoetius: Eurycleia: An old woman servant , a devoted nurse to both Odysseus and Telemachus in their youth: Eurymachus: A suitor who is an evil coward. But Penelope did not believe Odysseus was dead, thus her dithering and delaying tactics with weaving the shroud. Before the murder of Polonius, Hamlet and Gertrude were having an argument, Hamlet says he will set a mirror up in front of her, then slice her open so that she can see her own internal organs. Odysseus wanted to kill the suitors so badly that we got the chance to, he didnt even know where to start and he just killed everyone who was in front of him. In book one of the Odyssey, Odysseus was on an island with Calypso because she wanted She insults him and calls him a coward while also questioning his manhood which makes Macbeth come to a realization that not killing the king is the way of a coward and he is motivated to carry out the plan and murder the king because of Lady Macbeths insults and speech that she gives him. No matter how poorly the suitors may treat the old beggar, Odysseus and Telemachus are to bide their time and refrain from striking back until the moment is right. "My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." To stop Odysseus from killing all the suitors, Eurymachus does everything but To stop Odysseus from killing all the suitors, Eurymachus does everything but a. blame everything on Antinous c. ask for a fair fight with Odysseus b. offer to repay Odysseus d. admit that Odysseuss anger is Telemachos ' house. Instant downloads of all 1441 LitChart PDFs seer who came to Ithaca with Telemachus. 1)Odysseus trusts both the swineherd and the cowherd, Eumaeus and Melanthius, to help him kill off all the suitors. On the other hand, Aunt Alexandra has also shown the reader signs that she values her familys reputation. The bed is a permanent piece of furniture, representing the stability of the marriage between Odysseus and Penelope. however score: 0 Odysseus should have given the suitors another option (reveal himself, tell them to leave?) Eurycleia seems to thoroughly subscribe to the expectations of her class and gender, and she totally lacks solidarity with the other Maids. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class.. What does Odysseus do after the suitors offer restitution for what they did? Book XX. Odysseuss fight against the suitors of Penelope is the supreme ordeal of his epic journey. Where is Odysseus? Whom does Odysseus trust to help him defeat the suitors? All they did was aide the suitors. Since hundreds and of thousands of women have done it in the name of love (p. 1401). Immediately after praying, Odysseus takes an amazing shot at the suitor Antinoos, and it was a shot that no other man could have made.4 Although Zeus, Athena, and Apollo are the only ones who directly help Odysseus kill the suitors, the other gods do not have a problem with the killing of the suitors. sources: common sense? We can clearly see that Hamlet is deranged based on what he says to his mother. Antigone is defiant and free spirited while Ismene is cautious and uses her gender as an excuse to limits herself. Telemachus. During Penelopes prayer to the Gods, she tries to appeal to the Gods by reminding them of how much Odysseus, Penelopes husband, sacrificed for them, but she wants them to remember it now for my sake, save my darling son (Od. Why wont Nausicaa let Odysseus ride in her cart? Lady Macbeth fears for his sanity while Macbeths thanes are no longer loyal to him. However, the relationship with Logan does not satisfy Janies desire for true, unconditional love. Then Odysseus shot Antinous in the throat and went on the kill all of the Suitors with the help of Telemachus and two herdsmen. Macbeth shows no worry towards his unloyal thanes though, only focusing on what he can do to continue holding onto the crown. World Literature 10 How does Penelopes portrayal differ from the [] The Odyssey Summer Reading Assignment The two people who are cruel to Odysseus the beggar are Antinoos and the other beggar Iros. Immediately after praying, Odysseus takes an amazing shot at the suitor Antinoos, and it was a shot that no other man could have made.4 Although Zeus, Athena, and Apollo are the only ones who directly help Odysseus kill the suitors, the other gods do not have a problem with the killing of the suitors.